Cereal Milk Ice Cream

So I haven’t posted in a while.  I was busy, broke, and many other things.  However, I was given a good bit of advice, “Be too stupid to give up.”  I mulled it over for a good long while and decided to ignore my bank account and lazier self and keep on the keepin’ on.

my discount won't buy me Trix

But it was too hot to bake, so I made ice cream instead.  Cereal milk ice cream.  I was always the kind of gal who let her milk get warm at the dinner table.  These days I blame it on the fact that the milk was skim, which I do still buy on occasion, but it usually goes bad because fat free milk is simply unacceptable for baking and drinking.

cooking custard

The skim milk sitting beneath my morning cereal, however, got slurped up faster than the cereal itself.  So when a friend told me about the flavor he had at Momofuko’s Milk Bar in the city, I knew I was hooked – AND I HADN’T EVEN TASTED IT YET!  I was hooked on just the idea.

easy, freezy, beautiful

See, my mom never really bought junk food when I was younger, and still doesn’t, and truth be told, neither do I, much to my boyfriend’s dismay.  However, she did indulge us in her purchase of sugary cereals.  My favorite cereal was always Honeycomb, but in a strange and unexpected twist, the best milk hid under a bright colorful mound of Trix – mildly fruity and sweet enough to classify as dessert any day.  I don’t get Trix at 20% off, though, so I settled for what I hoped would be the next best thing, and it was.

i think it qualifies as a breakfast-appropriate ice cream

Cereal Milk Ice Cream


1 ½ cups whole milk, divided

1 cup heavy cream

1 ½ cups cereal of your choice

¼ cup sugar (or less, depending on your cereal)

3 egg yolks


  • Combine 1 cup whole milk and 1 ½ cups cereal in a bowl.  Allow to set in the refrigerator for no more than 30 minutes.  Set a timer and don’t forget about it!
  • Drain the milk into a saucepan and discard the soggy cereal.  Add the ½ cup whole milk and sugar.  Heat gently and stir, allowing the sugar to dissolve.
  • Meanwhile, whisk the egg yolks until lighter yellow and frothy.  Temper the yolks by slowly pouring some of the cream into the bowl while whisking.  An extra set of hands, or a stand mixer helps a ton!  Once the yolks have been warmed gently, pour them into the milk and sugar mixture while whisking.
  • Cook over low heat, stirring constantly until the custard thickens.  It should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon.
  • Place 1 cup heavy cream in a bowl, place a fine mesh strainer over the bowl.  Once the custard has thickened, strain it into the cream, and stir, checking for any stray custardy lumps.
  • Allow to refrigerate overnight, then churn according your ice cream maker’s instructions.

I’ve always found the hardest part of making ice cream is waiting for it to be ice cream consistency, which can take up to 8 hours!  Yuck!  Solve this dilemma by churning the custard first thing in the morning while you get ready for work.  When you get home, you’ll have delicious ice cream ready in time for dessert!

I topped mine with the fruity bunnies I used to flavor the milk, but considered mixing them in.  Next time my mom visits me, I’m definitely making Lucky Charm ice cream, and plan on mixing in the marshmallows.


5 thoughts on “Cereal Milk Ice Cream

  1. yummmmm Alex. Get this in my hot little hands – quick!

    Since I still live at home (double Yikes), I have the luxury of borrowing Mom’s ice cream maker. And I’m pretty sure you just inspired me to whip up a batch of creamy goodness. Muchas gracias, chickie!

  2. YUMMY!! I wish you had gotten inspired to make this when I was there!! Ice cream is the best because you can make it any flavor you want! Great idea.

  3. I was totally going to suggest Lucky Charms! That would be awesome!
    Glad you’re blogging again!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s